854 Asbury Avenue,
Ocean City, NJ, 08226
Fine Foods
At Agape Gourmet, we celebrate flavor, craftsmanship, and quality with our thoughtfully curated Fine Foods Collection. From rare cheeses and small-batch charcuterie to award-winning chocolates, crackers, and condiments, every item on our shelves is handpicked for its taste, story, and sourcing. Visit us on Asbury Ave. in Ocean City, NJ.
Fine Foods
Explore our extensive selection of fine foods, specialty oils, gourmet coffees, and more — visit us on Asbury Avenue in Ocean City to taste the difference.
Blue Mountain Coffee
Known as one of the most sought-after coffees in the world, Jamaican Blue Mountain Coffee is prized for its exceptionally smooth, low-acid flavor profile. Grown at high elevations in the Blue Mountains of Jamaica, this rare bean develops slowly in rich volcanic soil, producing a balanced cup with notes of chocolate, floral undertones, and a naturally sweet finish.
At Agape Gourmet, we proudly brew 100% authentic Blue Mountain Coffee in-house, delivering a premium coffee experience that’s both bold and silky-smooth — no bitterness, just pure flavor. Whether enjoyed hot or over ice, it’s a true treat for coffee lovers who appreciate quality in every sip.
Olive Oils
At Agape Gourmet, we carry a carefully curated selection of premium olive oils that bring exceptional flavor and quality to your kitchen. Sourced from award-winning producers and small-batch artisans, our oils range from smooth and buttery to bold and peppery — perfect for dipping, drizzling, or finishing your favorite dishes.
Explore cold-pressed extra virgin olive oils, infused varieties like garlic, lemon, and chili, and seasonal imports that showcase the best of the Mediterranean. Whether you're dressing a salad, enhancing a charcuterie board, or gifting a gourmet food lover, our olive oils are the perfect addition to any table.
Vinegars
Agape Gourmet offers a remarkable collection of artisan vinegars, including rare balsamic vinegars aged up to 100 years. These rich, syrupy vinegars are crafted using traditional methods and aged in wooden barrels to develop deep complexity, balanced sweetness, and smooth acidity.
From everyday favorites to luxurious finishing vinegars, our selection includes:
-
100-Year Aged Balsamic – intensely flavorful, perfect for drizzling on cheese, fruit, or desserts
-
Flavored Balsamics – including fig, raspberry, and white peach for unique pairings
-
Wine & Apple Cider Vinegars – bright, crisp options for salads, marinades, and more
Elevate your cooking and entertaining with vinegars that bring depth, richness, and heritage to every dish.
Valente PAsta
Made in small batches and air-dried for old-world texture, Valente Pasta brings the heart of traditional Italian craftsmanship to your kitchen. Crafted with simple, high-quality ingredients and bronze-cut for a perfect al dente bite, this pasta is a pantry staple elevated to gourmet status.
Available in a variety of unique shapes and flavors — including classic durum wheat, spinach, roasted garlic, lemon pepper, and more — Valente Pasta pairs beautifully with everything from light olive oil dressings to rich, hearty sauces.
Whether you're cooking for a weeknight dinner or a special occasion, Valente delivers authentic texture and flavor that stands out in every dish.
Al dente Pasta
Since 1981, Al Dente Pasta Company has been crafting premium pasta that cooks in just 3–5 minutes — without compromising on texture or flavor. Made in small batches using traditional techniques and natural ingredients, Al Dente pasta is bronze-cut for that ideal, sauce-grabbing surface and always delivers a perfectly tender, al dente bite.
From classic egg fettuccine to bold flavors like garlic parsley, spinach, and whole wheat, Al Dente Pasta offers a gourmet foundation for everything from weeknight dinners to special gatherings.
Fast, flavorful, and uncompromising in quality — it’s artisan pasta made simple.
Chocolates
Chocopologie
Vendhi
Artisan-crafted treats with a focus on texture and bold flavor — small-batch indulgence at its best.
Smith Raw Milk Chocolate
Smooth and naturally creamy, this raw milk chocolate delivers rich cocoa flavor with a clean finish.
Somerdale / Reypenaer
Award-winning English and Dutch cheeses — aged to perfection with bold, complex flavor profiles.
Cypress Grove
American-made goat cheeses with creamy textures and unique flavor blends — from mild to tangy.
Snacks
Lark Fine Foods (Cookies)
Crisp, buttery cookies with sophisticated flavors — perfect for pairing with coffee, tea, or cheese.
Savoursmiths (Chips)
Luxuriously flavored British potato chips made with real ingredients and unique gourmet seasonings.
Top Seedz (Chips)
Crispy, seed-packed crackers that are organic, gluten-free, and full of flavor and crunch.
Meats
Short Creek Farm
Pasture-raised, handcrafted charcuterie with bold flavor and old-world techniques.
Salt Wine (Meats)
Premium cured meats made with red wine and sea salt — rich, savory, and perfectly balanced.
Foustman’s
Dry-cured, naturally smoked meats made in San Francisco — gluten-free, nitrate-free, and bold.
Jams
Blake Hill
Award-winning jams and preserves with inventive pairings — small-batch made in Vermont.
Cheeses
Plymouth Cheese
Historic Vermont cheddar with rugged texture and rich, sharp flavor — hand-waxed and aged.
Birdie
Creamy, funky, and small-batch — a unique cheese line with personality in every bite.
Decadent, hand-crafted chocolate from Denmark — rich, elegant, and made with premium ingredients.